Ed Sheeran allegedly copied Marvin Gaye classic

An EFL and ESL English Lesson

Lesson Collection
A photo of guitar chords.

Date: 1st May 2023

Level: C1 Advanced

Grammar: Adverbs of certainty and uncertainty

Topics: Politics & Law, Music, Money & Careers

Printables: 10-Page Lesson, Single-Page Lesson

Worksheets: Reading, Grammar, Vocabulary, Writing

Lesson

Text

Ed Sheeran allegedly copied Marvin Gaye classic

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a trial in court over claims he allegedly copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on accusations that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is undoubtably a copy of the famous R&B hit.

The lawsuit was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his composition on the chord progression and the chord harmony of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played seamlessly together, are exclusively Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million settlement.

Sheeran’s legal team supposedly acknowledged the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have proposed that the musical parts are common and cannot be copyright. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.

Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it subconsciously, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is partially to blame. He says musicians are issuing lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of streaming music.

Information sources (external links): cbsnews.comvariety.com

top

Warm-up activities and vocabulary

Activities:

Finish the sentence — “Music streaming has affected...”

What does the phrase “thinking out loud” mean?

Write a fifteen word sentence about your favourite musician. Let others try to guess who it is.

Vocabulary:

1. Scan the text and find a word or phrase that means:

  • A. case (paragraph 1)t...
  • B. certainly (paragraph 1)u...
  • C. song (paragraph 2)c...
  • D. fully (paragraph 2)e...
  • E. accepted (paragraph 3)a...
  • F. suggested (paragraph 3)p...
  • G. by chance (paragraph 3)c...
  • H. payment (paragraph 4)c...
  • I. copying (paragraph 4)p...
  • J. internet broadcast (paragraph 4)s...
Answers
  • A. trial, B. undoubtably,  C. composition,  D. exclusively,  E. acknowledged,  F. proposed,  G. coincidentally,  H. compensation,  I. plagiarism,  J. streaming

2. What does the italicised phrase below mean — fullyslightly, or not?

  • the music industry’s business model is partially to blame
Answer
  • slightly

3. Which word below doesn’t belong?

  • harmony — composition — settlement — chord
Answer
  • settlement

top

Reading comprehension match-up

  1. Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a trial in court over claims he allegedly...
  2. Sheeran is up against an American jury on accusations that his...
  3. The lawsuit was started by the estate of...
  4. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his composition on the...
  5. They claim that these two parts of the song, when...
  6. They demand a...
  7. Sheeran’s legal team supposedly acknowledged the similarities of the two songs privately, but...
  8. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally...
  9. Not all attorneys and lawyers...
  10. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from...
  11. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if...
  12. But he says the music industry’s...
  13. He says musicians are issuing lawsuits more often now due to...
  1. $100 million settlement.
  2. a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”.
  3. Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye.
  4. copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”.
  5. it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.
  6. they have proposed that the musical parts are common and cannot be copyright.
  7. 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is undoubtably a copy of the famous R&B hit.
  8. played seamlessly together, are exclusively Gaye’s intellectual property (IP).
  9. earning less income as a result of streaming music.
  10. Sheeran copied it subconsciously, it is still plagiarism.
  11. agree with Sheeran, however.
  12. chord progression and the chord harmony of “Let’s Get It On”.
  13. business model is partially to blame.
Answers
  • 1D, 2G, 3C, 4L, 5H, 6A, 7F, 8E, 9K, 10B, 11J, 12M, 13I

worksheet  |  interactive  |  top

Phrases, synonyms, and antonyms match-up

Match the words on the left to their endings to make phrases from the text.

  1. bound
  2. intellectual
  3. a trial
  4. business
  5. singer-
  6. legal
  7. co-
  8. chord
  9. streaming
  10. civil
  1. team
  2. songwriter
  3. progression
  4. property
  5. rights
  6. in court
  7. music
  8. to happen
  9. model
  10. wrote
Answers
  • 1H, 2D, 3F, 4I, 5B, 6A, 7J, 8C, 9G, 10E

Match the words on the left from the text to their synonyms.

  1. settlement
  2. accusation
  3. blatant
  4. suppose
  5. dismiss
  1. obvious
  2. ignore
  3. believe
  4. deal
  5. claim
Answers
  • 1D, 2E, 3A, 4C, 5B

Match the words on the left from the text to their antonyms.

  1. exclusive
  2. subconscious
  3. coincidence
  1. conscious
  2. shared
  3. intentional
Answers
  • 1B, 2A, 3C

interactive  |  top

Grammar pairs cloze: adverbs of certainty and uncertainty

  1. A. exclusively / B. allegedly
  2. A. coincidentally / B. undoubtably
  3. A. blatantly / B. dismissively
  4. A. supposedly / B. seamlessly
  5. A. exclusively / B. partially
  1. A. subconsciously / B. supposedly
  2. A. dismissively / B. blatantly
  3. A. coincidentally / B. allegedly
  4. A. subconsciously / B. undoubtably
  5. A. seamlessly / B. partially

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a trial in court over claims he 1._______________ copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on accusations that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is 2._______________ a copy of the famous R&B hit.

The lawsuit was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran 3._______________ based his composition on the chord progression and the chord harmony of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played 4._______________ together, are 5._______________ Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million settlement.

Sheeran’s legal team 6._______________ acknowledged the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have proposed that the musical parts are common and cannot be copyright. Sheeran has publicly acted 7._______________ of these lawsuits in the past, saying that 8._______________ it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.

Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it 9._______________, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is 10._______________ to blame. He says musicians are issuing lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of streaming music.

Answers
  1. 1B, 2B, 3A, 4B, 5A, 6B, 7A, 8A, 9A, 10B

worksheet  |  interactive  |  top

Vocabulary gap-fill cloze

  1. proposed
  2. streaming
  3. harmony
  4. trial
  5. composition
  1. copyright
  2. issuing
  3. accusations
  4. acknowledged
  5. settlement

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a 1._______________ in court over claims he allegedly copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on 2._______________ that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is undoubtably a copy of the famous R&B hit.

The lawsuit was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his 3._______________ on the chord progression and the chord 4._______________ of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played seamlessly together, are exclusively Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million 5._______________.

Sheeran’s legal team supposedly 6._______________ the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have 7._______________ that the musical parts are common and cannot be 8._______________. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.

Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it subconsciously, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is partially to blame. He says musicians are 9._______________ lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of 10._______________ music.

Answers
  1. 1D, 2H, 3E, 4C, 5J, 6I, 7A, 8F, 9G, 10B

worksheet  |  interactive  |  top

Writing cloze

Spell the missing words correctly.

  1. r t a l i
  2. n i c u t s c a o s a
  3. o d n u b y t u b a l
  4. a u s l t i w
  5. o m n c o s i p i t o
  6. m a h r o y n
  7. c u l s e i e l v y x
  8. n e t s e l e t m t
  1. k o l d a c n w e d e g
  2. o r p o s d e p
  3. y r o c p i t h g
  4. i v c l i
  5. l i a y r t a p l
  6. s g i u n i s
  7. t r a s i g m n e

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a 1._______________ in court over claims he allegedly copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on 2._______________ that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is 3._______________ a copy of the famous R&B hit.

The 4._______________ was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his 5._______________ on the chord progression and the chord 6._______________ of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played seamlessly together, are 7._______________ Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million 8._______________.

Sheeran’s legal team supposedly 9._______________ the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have 10._______________ that the musical parts are common and cannot be 11._______________. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.

Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A 12._______________ rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it subconsciously, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is 13._______________ to blame. He says musicians are 14._______________ lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of 15._______________ music.

Answers
  • 1. trial, 2. accusations, 3. undoubtably, 4. lawsuit, 5. composition, 6. harmony, 7. exclusively, 8. settlement, 9. acknowledged, 10. proposed, 11. copyright, 12. civil, 13. partially, 14. issuing, 15. streaming

worksheet  |  interactive  |  top

Fill-in consonants

Fill-in the missing letters: d k p s w

_inger-_ong_riter Ed Sheeran face_ a trial in court over claim_ he allege_ly co_ie_ the Marvin Gaye cla__ic from 1972 “Let’_ Get It On”. Sheeran i_ u_ again_t an American jury on accu_ation_ that hi_ 2014 _ong “Thin_ing Out Lou_” i_ un_oubtably a co_y of the famou_ R&B hit.

The la__uit _a_ _tarte_ by the e_tate of Ed Townsend, _ho co-_rote the _ong _ith Gaye. Townsend’_ family allege that Sheeran blatantly ba_e_ hi_ com_o_ition on the chor_ _rogre__ion an_ the chor_ harmony of “Let’_ Get It On”. They claim that the_e t_o _art_ of the _ong, _hen _laye_ _eamle__ly together, are exclu_ively Gaye’_ intellectual _ro_erty (I_). They _eman_ a $100 million _ettlement.

Sheeran’_ legal team _u__o_e_ly ac_no_le_ge_ the _imilaritie_ of the t_o _ong_ _rivately, but they have _ro_o_e_ that the mu_ical _art_ are common an_ cannot be co_yright. Sheeran ha_ _ublicly acte_ _i_mi__ively of the_e la__uit_ in the _a_t, _aying that coinci_entally it i_ “boun_ to ha__en if 60,000 _ong_ are being relea_e_ every _ay on Spotify”.

Not all attorney_ an_ la_yer_ agree _ith _heeran, ho_ever. A civil right_ attorney, Ben Crump, _ay_ _heeran too_ the I_ from a blac_ arti_t _hom he “_oe_n’t feel a_ _orthy a_ com_en_ation”. Mu_ic an_ entertainment la_yer Charlie Sanders a___ that even if _heeran co_ie_ it _ubcon_ciou_ly, it i_ _till _lagiari_m. But he _ay_ the mu_ic in_u_try’_ bu_ine__ mo_el i_ _artially to blame. He _ay_ mu_ician_ are i__uing la__uit_ more often no_ _ue to earning le__ income a_ a re_ult of _treaming mu_ic.

top

Cool-down discussion, game, and keywords

Discussion questions:

  • Is it hard to earn a living from art?
  • Why do musicians do cover songs? Do you have a favourite cover song?
  • How do people become musicians in your country?
  • What are the pros and cons of music streaming platforms?
  • What parts of a song structure can you name?

CEFR C1 10 lesson keywords:

Nouns: accusation, composition, copyright, harmony, settlement, trial

Verbs: acknowledge, issue, propose, stream

Beginning with each letter below, think of a word to do with music.

  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • E
  • F
  • G
  • H
  • I
  • J
  • K
  • L
  • M
  • N
  • O
  • P
  • Q
  • R
  • S
  • T
  • U
  • V
  • W
  • X
  • Y
  • Z

top

Interactive exercises

Reading comprehension interactive match-up

Select the correct answers from the dropdown menus

Ed Sheeran allegedly copied Marvin Gaye classic
Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a trial in court over claims he allegedly...
Sheeran is up against an American jury on accusations that his...
The lawsuit was started by the estate of...
Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his composition on the...
They claim that these two parts of the song, when...
They demand a...
Sheeran’s legal team supposedly acknowledged the similarities of the two songs privately, but...
Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally...
Not all attorneys and lawyers...
A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from...
Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if...
But he says the music industry’s...
He says musicians are issuing lawsuits more often now due to...

A. $100 million settlement.

B. a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”.

C. Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye.

D. copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”.

E. it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.

F. they have proposed that the musical parts are common and cannot be copyright.

G. 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is undoubtably a copy of the famous R&B hit.

H. played seamlessly together, are exclusively Gaye’s intellectual property (IP).

I. earning less income as a result of streaming music.

J. Sheeran copied it subconsciously, it is still plagiarism.

K. agree with Sheeran, however.

L. chord progression and the chord harmony of “Let’s Get It On”.

M. business model is partially to blame.

worksheet  |  lesson  |  top

Phrases, synonyms, and antonyms interactive match-up

Select the correct matches from the dropdown menus

Phrases
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Synonyms
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Antonyms
16.
17.
18.

lesson  |  top

Grammar pairs interactive cloze: adverbs of certainty and uncertainty

Choose the correct options from the pairs

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a trial in court over claims he
1.
copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on accusations that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is
2.
a copy of the famous R&B hit.
The lawsuit was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran
3.
based his composition on the chord progression and the chord harmony of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played
4.
together, are
5.
Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million settlement.
Sheeran’s legal team
6.
acknowledged the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have proposed that the musical parts are common and cannot be copyright. Sheeran has publicly acted
7.
of these lawsuits in the past, saying that
8.
it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.
Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it
9.
or not, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is
10.
to blame. He says musicians are issuing lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of streaming music.

worksheet  |  lesson  |  top

Vocabulary gap-fill interactive cloze

Select the correct answers from the dropdown menus

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a
1.
in court over claims he allegedly copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on
2.
that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is undoubtably a copy of the famous R&B hit.
The lawsuit was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his
3.
on the chord progression and the chord
4.
of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played seamlessly together, are exclusively Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million
5.
.
Sheeran’s legal team supposedly
6.
the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have
7.
that the musical parts are common and cannot be
8.
. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.
Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A civil rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it subconsciously or not, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is partially to blame. He says musicians are
9.
lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of
10.
music.

worksheet  |  lesson  |  top

Interactive writing cloze

Type the words correctly in the boxes

Singer-songwriter Ed Sheeran faces a
1.
in court over claims he allegedly copied the Marvin Gaye classic from 1972 “Let’s Get It On”. Sheeran is up against an American jury on
2.
that his 2014 song “Thinking Out Loud” is
3.
a copy of the famous R&B hit.
The
4.
was started by the estate of Ed Townsend, who co-wrote the song with Gaye. Townsend’s family allege that Sheeran blatantly based his
5.
on the chord progression and the chord
6.
of “Let’s Get It On”. They claim that these two parts of the song, when played seamlessly together, are
7.
Gaye’s intellectual property (IP). They demand a $100 million
8.
.
Sheeran’s legal team supposedly
9.
the similarities of the two songs privately, but they have
10.
that the musical parts are common and cannot be
11.
. Sheeran has publicly acted dismissively of these lawsuits in the past, saying that coincidentally it is “bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify”.
Not all attorneys and lawyers agree with Sheeran, however. A
12.
rights attorney, Ben Crump, says Sheeran took the IP from a black artist whom he “doesn’t feel as worthy as compensation”. Music and entertainment lawyer Charlie Sanders adds that even if Sheeran copied it subconsciously or not, it is still plagiarism. But he says the music industry’s business model is
13.
to blame. He says musicians are
14.
lawsuits more often now due to earning less income as a result of
15.
music.

worksheet  |  lesson  |  top

Thanks for using this lesson!

Did you enjoy this lesson? Click these links to share this lesson on Facebook or share on Twitter.

A bit more on the same topics...

9th September 2022
A photo of Big Ben.

Liz Truss takes upon prime minister role

Level: B2

Grammar: Formal prepositions

Topics: Politics & Law - Society & Lifestyle - Money & Careers

Lesson
25th October 2022
A photo of the Spotify app.

Taylor Swift’s new album Midnights breaking records

Level: B2

Grammar: -ing verbs

Topics: Music - Apps & Social Media - Celebrities & People

Lesson

Printable Worksheets


More

Topic Selections


More

Grammar Guides


More

Warm-up Activities


More

Discussion Questions


More